A Letter to PETA on Rat Use in Laboratories

 

Dear PETA,

I understand your concerns about the use of rats in research and I believe they are completely valid. Rats are intelligent, social animals, and subjecting them to painful experiments and torturous euthanasia methods is inhumane. The boring, cramped living conditions lab rats are subjected to are also quite cruel. And for what? Often times the data gained from these experiments cannot even be applied to humans due to biological differences.

However, it is also important to recognize the benefits that come from using rats in scientific research. For example, rats have played a crucial role in the development of treatments for many human diseases, including cancer and diabetes. Furthermore, rats have a short reproductive cycle and a high rate of reproduction, making them useful in genetic research where human testing is unviable due to our long reproductive cycles. For these reasons, I don’t think it is reasonable to outright end the use of rats in research laboratories, however a lot can be done to reduce the number of rats used and to improve the conditions and treatment of research rats.

Adequate ethics rules must be put in place for rats, a group of animals left unprotected by the Animal Welfare Act. Researchers should try to minimize the use of rats in their experiments by using computer simulations, in-vitro cell cultures, and other methods of testing whenever possible. When alternative methods are not an option and rat research must be conducted, researchers should do everything they can to ensure humane treatment of the rats. Rats should be given better habitats with lots of enrichment and higher quality food as well as access to socialization and experiments should be designed to minimize the pain experienced by their rat subjects as much as possible.

In conclusion, I understand and appreciate your concerns about the use of rats in research, and I believe that it is possible to find a balance between scientific progress and ethical treatment of rats. I hope that this letter helps to spark continued conversation between those who use animals in research and animal welfare organizations like yourselves and I hope that ultimately we can get to a place where science can continue to progress while lab rats live happy lives full of enrichment and without unnecessary pain.

Sincerely,

Ezra Hill

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Moral Vision Statement

Image
It is common for certain groups of animals such as rats to be forgotten. People tend to have a disinterest for the species, which leads to a lack of knowledge of how these animals are treated and a disconnect emotionally. However, there should be a bare minimum understanding that rats can experience pain; they are not devoid from physical or mental/emotional suffering. Much like the animals that tend have higher value in Western society (i.e dogs and cats), rats should be given the right to humane treatment. To improve upon the treatment of rats, a few solutions could be implemented. Rats (and all lab animals for that manner) should be protected under the Animal Welfare Act, and that act should be reviewed and enforced by a reliable, non-affiliated third party. Rats should not be subjected to testing or additional suffering if it is not necessary for medical advancement (such as cosmetic testing) or if there is a feasible alternative. In addition, other daily inhumane acts such as cert...
Read more

The Social History and Domestication of Rats

Image
Are rats pets or pests, friends or foes? Rats and humans have a rich history of interaction. Rats have found ways to take advantage of human agriculture, infrastructure, and waste, while humans have found ways to use rats for research, companionship, and even military purposes. There are also negative ways we interact such as rats being vectors for disease and humans constantly trying to kill off rat populations with poison and traps. Before rats were domesticated by humans, our two species already had frequent interactions. When humans began shifting from hunter-gatherer lifestyles to lifestyles of agriculture, that opened the door for many human-rat interactions. Rats have been living in the homes of humans, eating food from human farms, and eating food stored in man-made structures for thousands of years, and they continue to do so. Anyone living in large cities can attest to the fact that rats love living in close proximity with humans, and they always find a way into our homes, fo...
Read more

Rat Ethology

Image
D espite what other people may tell you, It’s important to recognize that rats exhibit a very wide range of emotions. They generally aren't given credit for this because of our perception of them as pests. They experience emotions ranging from joy, sadness, and fear, to more complex ones like the ability to empathize or regret decisions. The ability to regret in rats was a large discovery because, before 2014, no mammal apart from humans was proven to have the capacity to experience regret. A study was done where a rat had the choice to wait in line for a favorite food or to find a less fulfilling meal elsewhere. After choosing to eat something else, some rats were observed going back to wait for the tastier food. The relevant part of this study is that the rats regretted leaving the line. Some may argue that they experienced disappointment only rather than regret, however, their orbitofrontal cortex became active, which is the same part of the brain that activates in humans when w...
Read more